The 2009 Teaching Awards were presented by the OCTM at the annual Awards Reception at the conference on November 19 in Cincinnati, Ohio. Awardees recognized were as follows:
| Renee Runyan |
Granville High School, Granville EVSD |
Central District (Secondary) |
| Debbie Haverstock |
Canfield Village Middle School, Canfield Local SD |
East District (Secondary) |
| Teresa Earnest |
Lakeview Intermediate School, Stow-Munroe Falls SD |
East District (Elementary) |
| Anita Cornish |
Keystone Middle School, Keystone |
Northeast District (Secondary) |
| Charlene Stephens |
Lt. Col. John Glenn, Parma City Schools |
Northeast District (Elementary) |
| Nora McDowell |
Freemont Ross High School, Fremont City |
Northwest District (Secondary) |
| Pamela Renter |
Hill View Elementary, Syvania |
Northwest District (Elementary) |
| Jodi Dunham |
Valley High School, Valley Local |
South District (Secondary) |
| Amanda Mickey |
Bishop Flaget, Columbus Diocese |
South District (Elementary) |
| Angela Hickenbottom |
Portsmouth West Elementary, Washington-Nile |
South District (Elementary) |
| Deana Dye |
Waterford High School, Wolf Creek Local |
Southeast District (Secondary) |
| Jill Butts |
Union Local Middle School, Union Local |
Southeast District (Elementary) |
| Lana Gerber |
Mt. Healty Junior High School, Mt. Healthy City |
Southwest District (Secondary) |
| Judy Meicenheimer |
Marshall Elementary School, Talawanda |
Southwest District (Elementary) |
| Sherry Shuman |
Centerville High School, Centerville City |
West District (Secondary) |
| Ann Muth |
John F. Kennedy Elementary School, Kettering City |
West District (Elementary) |
